but doest it mean that the scene was actually shot and then cut from the film for whatever reason? From what we are speculating the scene was partially shot, then made up of other unused shots and new CGI to create a new shot. I know what you are saying and agree with you, its just that this seems like a half assed effort in creating something that was never really there. ie the star destroyer scene in ESB SE is so obviously from RotJ footage. It just looks cheap, rushed and gimickie to sell. thats what Im trying to say. It is becoming so typical of Lucas these days.