logo Sign In

Post #431632

Author
Avatar
Parent topic
Info & Ideas: ESB and ROTJ Wishlist
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/431632/action/topic#431632
Date created
14-Aug-2010, 9:23 PM

Harmy said:

Really? If this is actually the original scene shot in 1980s I'll eat my shoes.

1)It's totally not really Mark Hamill.

2) He's not wearing the glove (M.H. said he remembers wearing it in that scene).

are you forgetting that he has not been shot

3) The dismountable lightsaber prop made especially for that scene is not use, insted the riddiculous stand in for M.H. screws with a screwdriver (apparently not actually doing anything) to convey the idea of finishing the sabre.

4) All that footage is shot prequel style (I'm pretty sure that it's the ROTS Vader costume in the Vader shots and it uses a weird video-like zoom and the whole thing just looks like a home made video to me - yes I know it is shot with a camera from a screen but I somehow don't think that is the reason it looks like it does).

isn't that a bit immature?

I think it sucks ass and it definitely should not be put into the movie, even if they restored the actual original scene. Much like the Jabba scene in SW it was originally cut for a good reason and should be kept out.

well that scene literally sent chills up my spine i cant's wait for the blue ray

edit

well i can think that part of the reason was to keep the surprise of luke's lightsaber

seeing that this is a wishlist thread, how would one go about incorpiraiting this scene into the movie