logo Sign In

Post #431273

Author
Erikstormtrooper
Parent topic
Return of the Jedi: Dan Edit - Clips Online (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/431273/action/topic#431273
Date created
13-Aug-2010, 10:59 AM

Dan,

I finally had a chance to watch your draft. I thought it was very good overall. Here are a few detailed comments:

  • Nice dialog changes for Jabba!
  • Using the beginning of the band scene to introduce the entrance of Bouush & Chewie: brilliant!
  • The line "Let's get you into something sexy" goes by too fast. I missed it the first time.
  • During Jabba's "send the band home" comment, the thermal detonator can be heard.
  • Overall I think the Rancor scene with Luke should be restored. I know it has some hokey moments, but I think you can probably cut around them. In your cut, Luke is suddenly captured and has lost his cloak.
  • The Sarlacc battle - The second skiff is suddenly there with Luke on it. I realize this is probably to remove Boba Fett, and is maybe necessary to avoid hard music cuts, but it's a little jarring.
  • A personal preference: I think Han's line "It's alright. I can see a lot better" is not as good as "trust me". That change will fit more with the new attitude you've given Han in this film.
  • Good job removing "certain point of view"!
  • Having Chewie's growl distract the Scout Trooper is good, but he still growls a moment before, which for some reason doesn't distract the trooper.
  • The funeral pyre scene didn't work for me. The flashback scenes felt a little forced. I recommend you revert to the original.
  • The end montage sequence was a little too different for me. The new music didn't feel right. Ending the movie with the freeze frame and fade felt un-Star Warsy. I don't know what to recommend for this. But I think the views of Bespin, Naboo, and Tatooine need to go. There's no reason to show those places celebrating. Maybe we can still see Coruscant celebrating, but I don't think it's necessary.