It appears that the "rapidoor" character, whoever he is, has launched into an attack of Ady's AVCHD release on the newsgroup.

http://comparescreenshots.slicx.com/comparison/71838

adywan's AVCHD vs. Original Premiere cap source

Whether you like the color change or not this is an absolutely pathetic
encode full of insane artifacting. I didn't know it was possible to fail this
badly. And it actually looks *worse* in motion. The pulsing is beyond belief.

Also note in the first shot how the color from Tarkin's yellow insignia and
Vader's green light almost completely disappear. This just goes to show that
you can't do color "correction" after the fact without losing something along
the way.

I'm all in favour of constructive criticism, but the "pathetic" and "epic FAIL" comments just make this guy out to be a real tool.