It's been 2 months and I've made some progress on my pile. Nobody asked, but here it is.
Recently Finished:
Force Unleashed DLC Missions - 100% DONE
Uncharted 2 - Single Player 100% DONE
Assassin's Creed II - 100% DONE
Batman Arkham Asylum - Campaign 100%, Might go back to Challenges
Castlevania: SotN - 200.6% DONE
BioShock 2 - Single Player 100%, 50% through MP Rank... might be done
Prototype - 1% and DONE
Left 4 Dead Co-op - 99% Lots of replay available, but will I get back to it?
Playing Now:
Banjo Kazooie: Nuts and Bolts - 33%
Mass Effect - 70%
Mercs2 Co-op: 55%
Lego Batman Co-op: 25%
Left 4 Dead 2 Co-op: 20%
Wario Land Shake It! - 10%
Gears2 Co-op 85%
LBP Co-op 90%
Burnout Paradise - 10%
Metroid Prime 3 - 50%
Resistance - 15%
Lotr: Conquest - 20%
Indy & Fate of Atlantis (again!)- 10%
Guitar Hero 5 - 10%
Terminator Redemption (for the old xbox! - 50%)
Own, but need to start:
Darksiders
Red Faction Guerilla
New Super Mario Bros. Wii
Conduit
Myst 4,5 + URU
Tex Murphy Overseer (again!)
Zelda Windwaker
Marvel Ultimate Alliance 2
Want to pick up for cheap
Prince of Persia Forgotten Sands, Cheap DJ Hero (~$20), Modern Warfare2, Mass Effect 2, Fallout 3: GotY, Borderlands, Monkey Island 2 SE, Zelda TP, and maybe Wolfenstein.
Most Looking forward to
Castlevania Lord of Shadows
Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
Force Unleashed II
I've also been contemplating a replay of BioShock (1) and Deus Ex (1). Just not enough hours in the day. :(