logo Sign In

Post #427526

Author
Chewtobacca
Parent topic
Harmy's STAR WARS TRILOGY "Partly Despecialized Edition" HD. !!! These version are now obsolete - Look for Despecialized Editions instead!!!
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/427526/action/topic#427526
Date created
27-Jul-2010, 10:19 AM

I am pleased that you appear to have fixed your problem, Harmy.  Here is some belated feedback on ROTJ.

*  Color correction was generally very good.  Colors did seem to vary between shots in certain sequences. At times, I thought the video looked a little too green.  Light-sabers looked great!  Overall, this is a great improvement on the SE.

*  The material that was replaced looked fine.  At times, I could tell that material had been replaced, but the quality was acceptable and the result was certainly preferable to watching the 2004 SE.

*  There were a few abrupt cuts that could be improved.  Most noticeable for me was the quick trim to the footage of the Bantha herd on Tatooine, which as SE additions go I have never minded much.  Moreover, Oola seemed to move position in the room quite quickly during the re-edited dance at Jabba's palace.  The rest of the editing was good.

This is a great improvement on the 2004 SE.  I do think that there is room for improvement, but I would certainly recommend watching this.  Thanks for all your work, Harmy!  :-)