I like what Cutter is attempting here. It's a no holds barred, if it sucks, it's out version, and I can respect that, cause that seems to be the reason for his edit.

I also can understand where rvpee is coming from. This is a major part of the movie. Palaptine and Maces saber fight is 13 seconds long on screen. And The time from when Anakin walks into the room to him cutting off Maces hand runs around 24 seconds. That is really fast, but If Cutters cool with that, I'm cool with that.

This edit will be a great version for people who've seen and know the movies. But I feel that anyone watching this version without having first watched the original would be like. "Ok, wait a second, well the hell is going on? I cant keep up.

But it seems that Cutter is doing this for the fans. So good job, and I look forward to seeing the final cut, cause I'm a Star Wars fan, who knows the movie inside and out 8)