rpvee said:

Too many quick cuts (...) too much isn't seen (...)the execution is just not as good as it should be.

Too much isn't seen ? but it's so ugly ! what can we do ?

There are "jumpy cut" in my part 3 but I think there is a good flow here.

Maybe You are really too much used with the original cut. You did not take the time to "digest" the new rhythm. Of course everything go faster, I cut a lot of things, so inevitably you feel a lack...but I think you just focus on it, and not on the essential :

Sidious is no more a gay, the Jedi are no more stupid bitches, no more stupids dialogues and too long hesitations (etc...) and there is now intensity when Sidious unleashed the dark side.

I'm really interested to know what you think about the original sequence. if you find my work "weak", what words do you use to qualify the work of Lucas and his team on this ?

There are so few good things in the original sequence that it was really a challenge. For you, my execution is weak...no problem, but what do you suggest ? keeping exactly the same ideas and the same content I selected, show me the way to a "strong execution" !

I worked so long on this sequence, I tried so many things... I can say, without pretension, that it will be hard to do a better cut. It's not a perfect cut of course...but it respects Star Wars, it do not destroy everything...

Thanks all for your comments ! I'm really glad you like it. Vaderios I need this sequence with Windu alone, awesome ! where can I find this ?

Jacobss said :

I'm sure the bad moments of prequel trilogy had nothing to do with actors. I think it is all fault of Lucas. The actors never knew what they have to act. And no matter what they did, Lucas was for sure always satisfied with their performace.

it's quite true