logo Sign In

Post #425715

Author
rcb
Parent topic
SW: SHADOWS OF THE OLD REPUBLIC (3-in-1 Prequel Film) ** V2 cut AVI Release Now Available
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/425715/action/topic#425715
Date created
18-Jul-2010, 12:50 PM

JasonN said:

rcb said:

 sounds like u just destroyed the films. i'm srry, but the Prequels are find as they are. They don't need to be touched! Yes i agree there are inconsistencies and bad acting, but i saw episode one when i was eight and up til now, still think there works of art.

.... I hope this was intended as a joke post.

1. Unless there's a mass of people that are throwing all the film prints, DVDs, videos, and other medias of the SW Prequel films into a massive bonfire of Doom that I am unaware of, I can safely say that me creating a couple of fanedits most certainly does not destroy the original films.

2. Au contraire, mon frere - the Prequels most definitely need to be touched and worked on.  

3. In terms of own personal preference, I do prefer my Prequel edit trilogy over the 3-in-1 SOTOR, but I think some people may find interest in a single film version that serves as a prequel story to the OT.

4. If you want to get technical, ALL films are artistic works.
The level of quality of the artwork, however, is always open to individual interpretation.

 not joke posting. i agree that all films are artistic works. Still, its annoying to continuously hear, "The PT sucks" or "It's so inconsistent" i could go on but i think you get the point. i just find that its unfair to compare the PT to the OT as they are completly different movies from two different eras. We would be saying the same thing if it was backwards.

One thing i think we can all agree on though, is that AOTC is the worse star wars movie ever!