SilverKey said:

And maybe this is not the right place for this, but you keep criticizing or parodying Anakin's (admittedly mostly awful) lines by saying they aren't Vader enough, but I'd like to point out that Anakin hasn't always been Vader.

do not misunderstand me Silverkey : I don't cut Anakin's lines because they aren't Vader enough...but just because they aren't Anakin enough - Anakin is not a jerk, a DJ or a surfer...and be a good person doesn't mean be silly.

Anakin's behavior is too close to our times. This is for me the most important mistake.

I use Vader to parodying Anakin just to show the difference of atmosphere, not because I want te see Anakin be evil every time.

I would have loved to see Anakin have moments of joy with Padme, deep feeling...and a great friendship with Obi-wan (and not : yes master, yes master, sorry master...all the time) but it's so badly done...The love story of Anakin and Padme should be an old school love story, not "Santa barabara" : )

I will respond to other posts tomorow !