adywan said:

ray_afraid said:

This is why I suggested cutting the explosion scene completely. It just doesn't add up. And all of the explanations take waay to much thought for such a quick scene. Having the walker fall over and then cutting to the rebel troops charging the battlefield is, in my opinion, the best option.

This would make no sense whatsoever. This is the rebels first little victory. They begin to think they can actually win this battle and then WHAM... they get their asses kicked. Take out the explosion and the scene falls flat.

But knocking the walker over is just as big a vicotry as blowing it up. It can no longer continue to advance and it can no longer fire it's weapons. That alone would be reason enough for the rebels to think they could pull off a win. I know you aren't gonna remove it and that's perfectly fine by me, but to say it would "make no sense whatsoever" is... well, wrong.

Cleopatra said:

So I know that this has probably been mentioned before, but why is Ady taking away the red AT-AT windows? I feel like they were meant to be red since they were depicted as such in the movie posters and paintings.

And, unlike the blue escape-pod door which was actually supposed to be blue in ANH, the red windows aren't very annoying. They're actually kinda creepy.

I'm assuming that it's being taken away because it doesn't match the interior shots. When we see out from the inside, it's a clear window.

(Ady beat me to it)