No! Not at all. Just because I think it would be a cool idea doesn't mean you have to agree with me.

I was hoping more people would pitch in. Plenty of members of this forum have played Bioshock, but it doesn't look like they are going to bite. That link you posted was very interesting. I had read the stuff about you originally being a ex-black ops guy who is now a cult deprogrammar and the kidnapped daughter bit. But I don't remember the island.

Now I am almost thinking that they should forget Rapture and go back to this story line for the next game. They could still tie it into Rapture and keep it feeling like a Bioshock game. There was some really cool stuff in there I'd still like to see. I enjoy the whole Island of Doctor Moreau vibe it had going.