gurgle1624 said:

Ripplin said:

gurgle1624 said:

What we all have to never forget is that if it wasn't for Lucas with all his flaws and errors included, none of this would matter.

That makes me think of a hypothetical situation: if we had never had the SEs or the PT or anything else that has tarnished our memories, and only had awesome versions of the OOT...would Star Wars fanediting even exist? If someone made their own SE, would they be viewed as Lucas is now, tampering with things that could've been left alone? (even if it was just fixing continuity errors or blemishes, and nothing else)

I appreciate that you also brought out the fact that Lucas is letting people mess with his movies. They even encouraged people to put stuff on YouTube before! That is pretty great and shouldn't be forgotten among all the nonsense. ;)

That is something to think about...some of the changes are trying to fix what the SE's have tarnished or have brought to the forefront...good observation and insight.

Thanks for the positive feedback. i was hoping I didnt get to badly ripped... :-), but I did get a box of band-aids for just such an occasion.

That is an interesting question... mmm.... probably not actually... People usually don't take action until there's a gross injustice or something first. Good question and you're right, it has lead to good things but in a round about way (Lucas's newer direction I mean, not your posting gurgle... lol). I was ready with a first aid kit myself... ^^ I didn't expect to escape unscathed and it's what happens when you're drawing the fire away from the cruisers... ;)