Sorceror said:

I think it would be a shame to throw away the effort that went into the matte reconstruction.

I definitely prefer Ady's work to the original shot, and would much rather see that new clip in ESB:R than nothing at all.

I don't like giving negative-sounding feedback for something I actually like, but I just wanted to throw it out there for Ady's consideration. As I've said before, if Ady wasn't open to getting feedback, he wouldn't bother posting such things in the first place.