haraldo23 said:
The whole Anakin-to-Vader transformation was one of the coolest things about PT. If your remove that then there's not much to anticipate. It's a different trilogy and I think it needs it's own ending.

I always felt that it was a little forced on George's part. There was no conflict to his transformation, he just seemed to say Okay imma' sith now. George had so many opportunities to make the transformation have depth and reason. You could say that him becoming the thing he tried to stop was poetic, but really it sounds like something an unimaginative kid would write. I would have felt more satisfied with Palpatine using Sith mind control than the latter. He really needed to start the journey towards the dark side in AOTC. His character in the final moments of Return of the Jedi was that of a good caring person. The prequels show none of that. He was an easy to manipulate pig head of a brat. George must have avoided watching the OT for details when making the PT.