The Definitive Collection LD set was not exactly cutting edge compared to what Criterion was doing at the time, and had been doing since 1985.
The DC has about the most sparse commentary track ever conceived, and trailers that look like they were copied from bootleg VHS.
The packaging was cheap, and the sleeves split open ten minutes after you opened the box. The book on Lucas had already been on the market for a while, and was a double dip for some fans.
The technical goofs in this set are legendary, and the sub-par much hyped THX mastering is still haunting us to this day. ;)