brash_stryker said:

Taking your ideas on board :)

In regards to the goodmusician thread, I'm wondering 2 things:

1. If the arena music you use in your youtube clip is from AOTC, where did goodmusician get it? It's not on the soundtrack cd to my knowledge.

2. Is there any way of you getting them uploaded anywhere so that I may have them? :)

A couple of other things I'm wondering if you noticed about my clip:

1. Anakin now tames the beast with a mind trick (the force theme plays)

2. If you ignore the direction of the deflected bolts in a few frames (which I intend to change), Kit Fisto now plays tennis with another jedi, who then deflects it towards Gunray.

Thoughts?

I've since changed the clip in a few ways, but intend to implement your suggestions if I can.

You'll have to forgive my slow responses...I only have internet at work right now.

I'll see what I can do to upload them this week...

I didn't notice the deflecting of the bolt! very nice!

Another thought I've had about rearranging shots in the battle is this: since you intend to replace all of the sound effects in this scene you should take every oppertunity to rethink where every shot is placed within the battle. the original version is very chaotic. there's no real build up to the jedi being surrounded. there no real thought as to where the characters are or how the battle is progressing. an example i thought of is: obiwan killing the green monster thingy. he kills it towards the end of the battle. my thought is "wouldn't obiwan kill this monster sooner? it's just getting in the way." I mean, that's MY thought process...but you get the idea. another: "Would Nute Gunray be hanging around once the jedi arrive?" ;)