The reviewer did have a point that it suited Anakin more to do something rash, like jump out the window to catch the droid. One point amongst many, actually.

I felt really bad after watching the reviews. Honestly, there were some faults of the prequels I hadn't noticed and other I refused to. I didn't like them much to begin with, even though I fall into the demographic they seem to be aimed at (I watched TPM on my 11th birthday as a gift, 16 when ROTS rolled out), but I'm on the verge of hating them now.