RedLetterMedia's Revenge of Nadine [TPM 108 pg Resp. [RotS Review+RotS Preview+ST'09 Reveiw+Next Review Teaser+2002 Interview+AotC OutTakes+Noooooo! Doc.+SW Examiner Rebuttal+AotC Review+TPM Review] — Page 16

My my once again some astute observations (with the same brand of humor that goes down well with this crowd).

Lots of useful pointers for fan editors to play with (maybe it's possible to swap Anakin with Obi wan jumping out the window) they both take a tumble just swap the tumbles around.

Maybe Padme could get shot through a window in Episode 3 leaving her in a bad way so she can die on Alderaan Etc.

What is the address to send away for those pizza rolls again?

The whole thing is up now.

It has lots of really useful pointers for fan editors and film directors alike.

So many missed opportunities and utter fluff ups.

I do hope he turns his eye to ROTJ too though because it sounds like he is ignoring where the rot set in.

I honestly couldn't stand listening to this guy for more than 5 minutes. How anyone can listen to him for 90 minutes, and then turn around and say they love it escapes me. He sounds like Napoleon Dynamite's retarded cousin from Chicago. I know a lot of people love his reviews, but I think that 90 minutes is way too long to spend watching someone dwell on a movie's problems, when you could spend that time watching an actual movie that you like.

"Borderline Obsessive" (how dare you change your post while I'm formulating an overly elaborate retort Tim).

Far from it.

It's dead centre of the main high street of Nerdsville, Capital City of Geekland in the continent of Retentivica on the Planet Toomuchtimeonhishands.

Which is basically next door to me.

Nice to hear a local boy done good.

Sorry 'bout the ninja edit. I did realize seconds after posting "borderline obsessive" how retardedly hypocritical that sounded, considering how much time I've poured into my Phantom Menace fan edit. :P

Timstuff said:

I honestly couldn't stand listening to this guy for more than 5 minutes. How anyone can listen to him for 90 minutes, and then turn around and say they love it escapes me. He sounds like Napoleon Dynamite's retarded cousin from Chicago. I know a lot of people love his reviews, but I think that 90 minutes is way too long to spend watching someone dwell on a movie's problems, when you could spend that time watching an actual movie that you like.

That's not his real voice. It's supposed to be funny.

Octorox said:

That's not his real voice. It's supposed to be funny.

And I find it hilarious...lord help me.

I still don't find his "I kill women" gimmick to be funny, but I'll at least note that he tried to make a joke out of it this time, as opposed to just showing tortured women and expecting a laugh.

He still makes some good points, but goes on forever, and forever, and forever. It's neat that he owns "Romeo and Juliet" but after the first clip, it doesnt really add anything.

I can't wait for his ROTS review which will be three times longer than the actual movie.

I'm waiting for the DVD of this.  Stop spoiling it for me!

;-)

***The first segment of this was pulled by "The Cartoon Network"?***

Was there a clip from Clone Wars cartoon? I don't Remember.

Someone has posted a collected version in WMV format on Demonoid.com.

Downloading now to see if real.

Got it from Demonoid, and it's the real deal.

If anyone wants to see the whole thing, then you may have to torrent it.

I highly recomend these reviews to any real Star Wars lover.  This Plinkett guy realy get's it.  

The Next Gen Star Trek reviews are great too.

Because the review was the number one video on youtube, it would seem Cartoon Network wants to get a piece of the attention so they've submitted what seems to be a completely false copyright claim.  There is no CN video material in the Part 1 AotC review, don't know the source of the background sounds, but that's no reason to question the video.  This is a False Claim and hopefully someone will take notice of this faulty practice.

here's a copy of the video:

http://noneinc.com/Archive/RedLetterMedia/(Part%201%20of%209)%20Star%20Wars%20Episode%202_%20Attack%20of%20the%20Clones%20Review.mp4

A very good review but not as fun nor focused than the previous one.

A bit too long I think.

But maybe it is because english is not my language. I perfectly understood all what he said on TPM review, but here, it's strangely more difficult to me, to follow everything he says, lol.

It's interesting that he says AOTC doesn't have a single bit of creativity in it, and then complains it doesn't have a standards fish out of water protagonist.

Akwat Kbrana said:

Blast! Part 1 has been taken down!

none said:

Because the review was the number one video on youtube, it would seem Cartoon Network wants to get a piece of the attention so they've submitted what seems to be a completely false copyright claim.  There is no CN video material in the Part 1 AotC review, don't know the source of the background sounds, but that's no reason to question the video.  This is a False Claim and hopefully someone will take notice of this faulty practice.

here's a copy of the video:

http://noneinc.com/Archive/RedLetterMedia/(Part%201%20of%209)%20Star%20Wars%20Episode%202_%20Attack%20of%20the%20Clones%20Review.mp4

Thanks for saving it, none.

btw, there will be a DVD available (including Part 1) "soon."

Here's a bonus feature for the DVD version:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T75CMlzRmF4

Group of friends (some hang out in the fan film forum of TF.n) got together to watch the Review.  Who knows maybe there will be lines of people waiting for entrance to parties when RotS gets reviewed!