Redlettermedia has started putting up his AOTC review (same style so if that offended you before it will again).

But there are some interesting points there which may help fan editors.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfBhi6qqFLA

I'm convinced that the only way to salvage anything from the PT is to do a major reshuffle and remaking whole sections.

That would mean having to go beyond even the best fan edits so far.

Things that spring to mind are getting rid of the clone mystery and have Yoda inspect the troops instead of Obi-Wan with a mind to limiting their use. And have the Senate order their use on Geonosis over the heads of the protesting Jedi.

Have Anakin jump after the assassin droid instead of Obi-Wan.

Have no direct link between Zam Wesell and Jengo (or better still Boba Fett) so he is just taking out a rival and have Obi-Wan link him to Geonosis.

Have Padme more keen on Anakin and have her take risks against his instincts leading him into the romance after being convinced by her family that she actually has feelings for him.

Have some actual speeder crashes in the Coruscant chase scene to emphasis the danger including some serious near misses for the heroes.

Have Anakin dream of slaughtering the Sandpeople and feel guilt for just dreaming about revenge as a Jedi (this would make her feel sympathy for him instead of making her run a mile from the psycho).