logo Sign In

Post #405603

Author
Angel
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/405603/action/topic#405603
Date created
28-Mar-2010, 8:43 PM

Lord Grievous said:

I really don't see why we need to change the background buildings in that scene, they could use some of Ady's colour correction, sure, but I don't see anything wrong or outdated about them.

The sky and *some* of the buildings in the back do scream matte painting, but I really like their designs. And I think that changing them with generic buildings would take away from the beauty of this shot.

Actually in older posts the coloring in GOUT was better from 2004 or adys from the point of view that it had more natural light and shadow behaviour.

Now i still support ady's coloring because the CG flyby doesnt match not even close to the GOUT colors.

I mention in earlier posts with the help of Imp fighter that the blending from the flyby and the static shot(leia's window) the buildings are in the wrong place as well many other elements.

There is nothing particural wrong with the buildings as i mentioned but as you can see ILM managed to make new CG buildings and mostly ignore the other architecture that appears in bespin. So from matter of continuity get rid of them if you can.

 

Thanks for the analysis on bespin savmagoett!:D:D:D

 

-Angel