Rogue Leader said:

Vader retrieves Lukes hand and lightsaber from the surface of Bespin. The hand was put into storage along with the lightsaber and used to create a Clone of Luke in "The Last Command" by Joruus C'boath.

However, further retconning now says that the hand was found in the bowels of Cloud City by an Ugnaught AND that Bespin has no surface and is a gas giant... Idiots...

Anyway, this makes that random object falling down from the hole after Luke lands on the weather vane ambiguous at best even though it should be Luke's hand/saber.

The first is an EU statement, that doesnt count :P

Well i always thought bespin was a gas giant even the planet from above was like all the rest in ESB... white with clouds(thanks the variation)

All the falling concept was to show depth and define what is bottom and what is top..

So simply remove the no sense falling object or show a visible broken piece from the city..(like an antenna piece like Tobar said) in Luke's close up shot.

IF it was his saber/hand wouldnt be following luke during his vein fall?

isnt the hand/saber was off several time before luke fell?

makes sense?

Monroville said:

Also, is it me or could something be done to the underside to show it extend a lot more into the background (more antennas, with the grid work extending back more, etc)?

Well assuming that luke fell into one of the many holes/tubes/veins then there should be visible hatches/doors in the rest of the area..

Plus again the live action set piece is different from the extended matte.

-Angel