RoccondilRinon said:
The trouble with both Yub Nub and its replacement is that they're so different, stylistically, from the rest of the score of the series. The result is that they call too much attention to themselves.
I completely agree with you RoccondilRinon, it needs to go more classic John Williams…
…
There was a mock-up I liked a while ago of an extended ending which used the concert version of the Force March included on the ROTS soundtrack album.
…
SSWR: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VUJL7c3-yro
Wow this is reeeeeally good, I mean compare to the original. Some very good ideas are putted here, Han's akward kiss back to leia removal, R2 & 3PO comment, the fleet going away in space (with more shots of Akbar, we all love that lobster man :) ), I know it repeating ESB but I just love that Falcon/Luke's x-wing flying apart shot and the hyperspace closing.
I like "the adventure continues" spirit of it, it fits well with the serial aspect of the saga. Overall it's simply "more Star Wars" great job!
I can think of some improvements though:
-keep the SE celebration around the galaxy shots, as it links the two trilogy
-shorten the Ewok celebration or enhance it with dialogs and chattering
-get Sebastian Shaw back of course
-Akbar's dialog is not great IMHO, change it to something else, like dialog with the heroes for example
-get rid of Han's "Yaooooh" at the end, it doesn't work with his previous state of mind, and it's silly
-beware of the "neverending ending" effect (à la Lord Of the Ring), try to make it not too long ;)
anyway great ideas here SSWR1…