vaderios said:

I didnt mind yoda look like weak.. In fact he is strong but stylistic speaking dark side is at its best.. so a deeper meaning is behind that..

Agreed. ;)

SilverKey said:

SSWR, I was just thinking of this: I like Anaking going over the lava-fall because it leaves us in the dark about his fate and it adds some mystery to Darth Vader's identity. How are you going to edit the movies to make it all work? Because as much as I love your ending for Anakin, it still won't be a surprise when Vader reveals himself to Luke in ESB: we met Anakin in the PT, know he was Obi-Wan's only apprentice, and we've seen him fall to the Dark Side over the course of the trilogy. What are your ideas to keep the mystery?

Well, the only real problem is knowing Anakin is Obi wans only apprentice. I don't have a good answer for this. But I'm not giving up hope yet... ideas? anyone? ;)

Bingowings said:

This might sound daft but what if you just had the truncated battle in the senate incorporating his entrance into the room which I've always loved and left it with Yoda apparently falling to his death (Yoda could plausible seem to have died then).

After that you could have the scene of Yoda making his escape with Bail.

This could work...