logo Sign In

Post #401307

Author
Chewtobacca
Parent topic
Star Wars OT & 1997 Special Edition - Various Projects Info (Released)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/401307/action/topic#401307
Date created
6-Mar-2010, 1:30 PM

Darth Editous said:


The noise reduction is just too bad in the GOUT for me to want to do this for every SE addition - it was okay for that checkpoint scene, but (for example) when they go past the next Ronto before stopping outside the Cantina, the GOUT quality is abysmal.

 

I had actually forgotten that I had asked!  I don't know what gave me the idea that you had a 480p project in the works.  

Thanks for the reply.  I did not realize that the other scenes that the SE changed were quite so bad on the GOUT .  That is a shame.  A high quality theatrical version must remain a dream then; though G-Force's latest offering is very good in terms of quality.  If that is the best looking the theatrical version becomes for the rest of my life, I can live with it.

I just cannot abide the SE additions.  The only film for which I do not feel quite so strongly about that is the 1997 SE of ESB, which thanks to Adywan we have in HD.  It is fortunate that ESB weathered the SEs relatively unchanged, although I wish the ROTJ take of Vader's shuttle arriving had been cut from the AVCHD, as that really irritates me.