Bingowings said:
Another comparison worth looking at is RLM70's and Confused Mathew's reviews of First Contact.
When I finally got to listen to his 2001 rant I was gobsmacked by just how asinine it was but it doesn't take away from most of his observations about the PT.
Yes, I agree he has a lots of good points in his PT reviews.
However, sometimes he don't think twice. exemple:
When he talks about the (awful) dialogue between Anakin and Amidala in EP3:
- You're beautiful
- it's because I'm so in love
- no, it's because I am so in love with you.
- So love has blinded you?
Matthew is condused once again... because he don't understand what it means. Well, I agree this dialogue is really bad written and really bad delivered. But it means something: Padme thinks she looks beautiful because happiness and love in her life makes her look beautiful, but Anakin saying no could be taken as "no, you're maybe not really beautiful, but I'm so in love with you that I see you as beautiful". And Padme is making fun of it.
God, I don't believe I'm writting an entire post about those shitty lines. They are bad, but they do have a sens. Sorta. What I'm trying to say his that that Matthew guy may have a great eye for plot holes and things like that, but when it comes to actualy think twice about something he don't understand, he don't take the time for it.
No wonder he did not like 2001.