zombie84 said:
He turned it from a utopian science ship to a naval battlecruiser in WOK.
he didn't change it that much. They always had the shields phasers and Photon Torpedoes.
zombie84 said:
He turned a then-serious sci-fi intellectual series into an outright contemporary comedy in VH.
apparently you've never seen The Star Trek episodes "The Trouble With Tribbles", or "A Piece Of The Action" or "I Mudd" The series contained alot of comedy.
zombie84 said:
He turned a idealistic view of the characters and humanity into racist, cold-war allegorys in UC. So much that members of the cast protested some of the lines they were given.
I agree that some of the lines some of the characters never would have said. Especially Kirk's "let them die". But as for the cold war allegorys that too was part of TOS. Watch episodes like "Errand Of Mercy" and "A Private Little War". The Klingons were always allegory to the Russians.
zombie84 said:
He re-wrote the series and what it was each time he went up to bat, and each time it alienated some fans because of the liberties and deviations,
funny I don't recall this alienation you refer to.
zombie84 said:
because finally the series was good!
in your mind maybe. But in mine and many others, the series was always good, and I don't feel alienated by Star Treks 2,4, and 6.