logo Sign In

Post #396517

Author
Vaderisnothayden
Parent topic
RedLetterMedia's Revenge of Nadine [TPM 108 pg Resp. [RotS Review+RotS Preview+ST'09 Reveiw+Next Review Teaser+2002 Interview+AotC OutTakes+Noooooo! Doc.+SW Examiner Rebuttal+AotC Review+TPM Review]
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/396517/action/topic#396517
Date created
6-Feb-2010, 5:31 PM

Bingowings said:

Vaderisnothayden said:

Akwat Kbrana said:

Vaderisnothayden said:

Are you telling me that in all his reviews he cracks jokes about killing women?

I know! How annoying! Don't you just hate it when people get hung up on peripheral issues and absolutely refuse to let matters go? Geez!

Misogyny is a serious issue and deserves to be addressed. Maybe you'd prefer to sweep it under the carpet, but I don't agree.

And for the record, I'd have been quite happy to let it go ages ago if other people would have let it go, but they've constantly come back telling me my view is mistaken. It should come as no surprise that I'd want to keep defending my view as long as it's being attacked. If they'd have shut up about it I would have done so too.

Ok, I've PMed Bingowings and asked if we could stop discussing the issue on the thread. Happy now?

 

Vaderisnothayden said:

Akwat Kbrana said:

Ah, civility, thou art a gem.

Find something more original to do than going around sniping at me. That's already been done. And for the record, I was more than civil enough to Bingo, considering he was basically telling me to fuck off from the thread.

I was going to avoid this thread for a while until I had something new to add about the content of the review.

But I can't allow myself to misrepresented.

I received a PM from the VINH asking me the details of RLM70's other reviews and what I thought the satire was all about and repeated what I've already posted here.

I did not (basically or otherwise) tell him to do as quoted above I merely asked if he had nothing new to add about the content of the review or the delivery it might make sense to not post here until he did (something I intended to do myself).

I'm going to do something I've never done before on this site and it pains me to do it but I'm going to add VINH to my otherwise empty ignore list.

If I think of anything to do with the content of the reviews I will post them here but I will not comment on anything else.

 

You weren't misrepresented at all. You just admitted you were telling me to get off the thread, which was what I said you were doing.

I did not (basically or otherwise) tell him to do as quoted above I merely asked if he had nothing new to add about the content of the review or the delivery it might make sense to not post here until he did (something I intended to do myself).

Amounts to the same thing. You were saying I had nothing to add and thus shouldn't post here. You were thus telling me to get off the thread, or, as I put it, you were "basically telling me to fuck from the thread". It may have not included such language, but the "basically" in my statement indicated I didn't mean you actually literally used such language. The meaning of what you said was as I represented it. You didn't merely ask if I had nothing new to add. You implied that I actually had nothing to add and your implication was that I should therefore get off the thread, and there was nothing in it about you doing the same, nor was there any indication that I had any right to come back to the thread at any later point. I didn't misrepresent you at all.

And I think you had no business telling me to get off the thread, which was why I was annoyed (but you notice I didn't put you on ignore for it).

And let's make this clear, all this happened ON THIS THREAD, out in the open, not in our PMs, so it's not like I said "Bingowings PMed me and told me to fuck off." I never claimed you telling me to get off the thread was anything to do with our PMs. So I don't see why you had to bring our PMing into it. I PMed you (earlier, before you told me here to get off the thread) to ask you if we could both stop debating the misogyny issue here, for the sake of the thread, and I asked you to clarify your views because I was interested in your opinion. You gave me your opinion and I gave you mine. That's all that happened and I never claimed anything else.

You know, I get accused of being touchy, but it amazes me how touchy some other people are here. People put people on ignore lists for nothing. If you can't take what I said without having to put me on your ignore list then it doesn't say much for you.