C3PX said:

Ghost said:

I still dont see why you guys are going on about the "humor" in this review. We are here to discuss the Star Wars movies and ways to make them better. Not here to discuss a fan edit of a hardly known, fan-made review of TPM. Lets take his good points out of his review, and move them into dicussion on this thread. Who cares about the other stuff.

If anything, we should all be glad he made this review, its a little step toward a potenial watchable edit of TPM. ;)

Kind of ironic in the course of the years this forum has gone from "trying to preserve Star Wars how it originally was, flaws and all" to "trying to make Star Wars better".

Forgot some people were still on about making a watchable edit of TPM. Trust me, with the edits already available, it has gotten as watchable as it ever will. And even that is not enough for me to ever want to watch it again (and I have made it no secret that it is my absolute favorite PT film).

Making Menace a good film rather than just a tolerably meh crap film, good luck with that. There is zero chance since it is supposed to be done at the writing stage of the script, and the choice of directors and actors.

Could the prequels be redone by Better directors, writers and actors, yes. Wood i care to watch them probably not the original prequels would have already ruined the experience for me.

Like fans wanting the original trilogy made and rebooted for a modern mindset to make them cooler and hip with the teen crowd like JJ did with Star Trek i would totally boycott any such attempt. I mean they would probably have Shia Lebouf as Han Solo, and either Hayden Christensen or Chris Pine for Luke Skywalker and there would be shaky cam and lens flares and lots of flashy video game graphics. Leia would be played by Keira Knightly, or Natalie Portman, or worse case scenario Megan Fox,lol.