xhonzi said:

The most common opinions here are: (as far as I can tell)

O-OT is the best.

PT is the worst.

The EU is here or there, but probably group consensus is that it's overall better than the PT. (Or tell me if I've assumed incorrectly. VINH, if you had to rank your disdain... would you put the PT or EU as the worst part of SW?)

So, any attempts to overwrite the standing EU with something that is more similar or takes its cues from the PT probably isn't going to be a very popular idea.

I gave my opinion earlier. I think the EU has a lot of crap in it, but also some awesomeness. I don't read all of it or much of it anymore, but I would rather have what's there currently than start over from scratch and have 100% garbage. Especially since so much of the EU was based on just the O-OT and a reboot would necessarily be based more on the "wholistic" 1-6 "saga" and "clone wars" show.

VINH, if you had to rank your disdain... would you put the PT or EU as the worst part of SW?

Um, the EU isn't real Star wars and has plenty shit but we're not expected to take it as seriously, so it's less of a problem.