Vaderisnothayden said:

Chewtobacca said:

You defend yourself over-aggressively, so I've no wish to talk to you further. You're on my ignore list from now on. No doubt you'll do the same, so that's an end to the matter.

God, what a friendly person.

Jeez, Chewtobacca, you are so unfriendly. You don't do anything around here except help people track down Ady's AVCHDs. You should be more friendly by insisting your opinion is fact, taking everything personally, lashing out whenever you are questioned, and so on.

Now, back on topic...

I finally watched the review and I really enjoyed it. I will say that the problems and failures of TPM have been well documented, and while his analysis was usually well done, I wasn't really that interested in that part of it. I mean, we get plenty of discussion on the failures of the PT here, right? What I really liked was the humor. I was never bored and when it was over I actually was surprised how fast it went by. However...

Vaderisnothayden said:

I found his humor often distasteful and misogynistic.

I agree with this (well, at least the misogynistic part, unless you want to argue that being misogynistic is distasteful, which I agree with, btw...where was I?). I didn't have a problem with most of the humor, but there were a few parts that were misogynistic and I would have liked to see that removed. I know they were part of his "character" but I still could have done without those bits.

Finally, I was surprised to find that I actually enjoyed his vocal treatment as well. Having heard just a bit of it previously, I didn't know if I could take it for 70 minutes. But for whatever reason, his voice grew on me the more I watched the review.