If I was all alone on a site taking BS, I know I'd like it if someone had my back. In fact I've been in his position before, and I know what it's like to feel all alone, like the whole fan community is against you. It sucks. Especially when you are right about an issue.
I don't recall anyone saying Lucas shouldn't put out both editions. Jimbo was just pointing out that there are many DVDs out there that don't have both editions, many of which I own! So what Lucas is doing here isn't unprecedented, and again, it's not lke he didn't tell us this was going to happen nine freakin' years ago.
In my opinion, you guys should have gotten over it by now. God knows Lucas has given you plenty of time.