I'm watching it now. Some of the criticism of the characters is total bull. Qui Gon and the TPM version of Padme have plenty personality. I have no trouble describing them, even if the people he recruited couldn't.
Also, what's with the way this guy talks? And his idea of what a protagonist should be is overly narrow.
"The new movies are about shoving as much crap into each shot as possible" -he's right about that.
He's also right about the lightsaber battles.