Ghost said:

Good points Akwat Kbrana.

I think the ending is powerful and can be made more powerful if edited correctly.

Padmes death sequence when it zooms in on the necklace was a very symbolic, emotional sequence. This to me was the best part of the ending.

I didnt care much about the Alderaan droping Leia off sequence, but that could potentially be taken out by Adywan to keep the mystery of Luke and Leia's relationship until ROTJ.

Overall, ROTS has the best storyline and gives Ady alot more to work with rather than TPM and AOTC.

Yes, TPM is most like the OT, but who cares, it won't be made into that good of a movie. Unless Ady has a secret plan. hmm...

Because of course, only Adywan can save the damn Prequels....

(I'm not putting Adywan or his skills down whatsoever... I just find it so fricken hysterical of these people that believe that he's the only editor out there who can properly edit the SW Prequels into the great "dream come true" movies that everyone desired the Prequels films to be... especially when you consider that there are dozens of edits already out there by numerous editors and that they've all proven that no single edit of the Prequels will be universally accepted by all as the best, since each person has his/her own ideas as to what constitutes as a "Star Wars" movie)

As for Episode 1... all I can say is that I'm very satisfied with my own Attack of the Federation fanedit of it and no review of TPM (no matter how many great points that it makes about the original film) can change my opinon of my edit or that its become my favorite of the Prequel stories because (as Akwat Kbrana said) it does genuinely feel the most like a Star Wars movie to me than either AOTC or ROTS ever did.