both AOTC and ROTS were just as horrible and f**ked-up as TPM
Not as bad though. Everything in AOTC until the battle of Geonosis is just as bad as all of TPM. When I say battle, I'm talking about after they escape the arena. The last part of the movie is promising.
Now, if ROTS can develop or build up to the ending, (which is very good)it can be up there with the OT. I really think the blueprint is right with this movie. If it is handled right, I really think this movie can be a very, very good movie. The emotion is there, the story is pretty good. With editing on Anakin, alot of ship landings taken out, less battle sequences, and overall flow improved, the movie will seem way better. Not to mention, Ady will have alot better tech to work with by the time he gets around to ROTS.