If anything, that analysis depressed me. If the film fails at such a fundamental level of story and characters then how can it be fixed?

Same here. This film may be so bad that there will only be limited things editors like Ady can do.

The main thing that will need to be fixed is the overall childish feel to the movie. I was even wondering if it would be possible to take Jar-Jar out of the film after they go underwater. After that he isn't needed at all.

If anything after watching the basics of how a movie should be made, ROTS actually has alot of promise. It has a good plot to work off of. It has the best acting of the PT, and it has a main character.

Most of the everything can be made better in ROTS. Like in the review he said something about how the duel between Vader and Obi-Wan has alot of emotion, but it is way too long. I totally agree there.

I can't believe how stupid TPM looks now.