There can be no "prequel person" response to this. You cannot defend a movie without a protagonist, introduction, plot, or sense. As weird as some of the off topic wanderings, you can't ignore that every point he made was right on the money, though maybe could have been put more eloquently.
His final conclusion that Lucas is a great idea man who needs to be restrained reminded me so much of Zombie that I wonder if he didn't have a part in it (RedLetter probably just read some of Zombie's articles).
One of the longer reviews, well made and seems to capture the spirit of the people who wanted TPM to be ANH2.
Its not that people wanted ANH2, we just wanted a movie that we could care about. I don't want to bash people who like TPM, I just think that it could use a little more deconstruction. The "coolest" parts of the movie are an unnecessary podrace and a 2 v 1 lightsaber battle that comes out of nowhere and could have been avoided. Like Jurassic Park III, I finally see TPM to be bunch of random action sequences tied together by the thinnest of plots.