ChainsawAsh said:

I'm still very apprehensive about what will happen when Ady gets his hands on them (and ROTJ, for that matter) - I think there's a high risk of a very intense backlash against Ady if he changes "too much" about the prequels/ROTJ.

"Star Wars" was a perfect film, and the GOUT was like being punched in the nuts.

Adywan took this perfect film, polished the presentationwith minimal interpretation/reworking, and gave us a masterpiece.

Even that parts of ANH:R that people quibble about are less that 2% of the actual product (Battle of the Heroes, electro needle, etc).

OBJECTIVELY, ANH:R is brilliant.

Once Adywan (or any fan editor) starts doing things more subjectively (which seems to be what he's implied his plans are for ROTJ) disagreements will naturally follow. I'm sure though, that even if I disagree with him on many subjective issues, ROTJ:R will be a hoot and a half to watch.