logo Sign In

Post #386386

Author
RoccondilRinon
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/386386/action/topic#386386
Date created
19-Nov-2009, 3:44 PM

What's that got to do with it, DE? That's not taking artistic licence with reality, it's playing with the conventions of the medium (it's borderline but I'd even count sound-in-space as this); and in any case, Spielberg did have a reason for making Schindler's List that way. Showing physical things in a physically impossible arrangement, or one which violates continuity, can't be excused by "artistic licence" unless it makes a point. The only way I can see that applying here is if it made the ship more menacing, say, than a realistic shot would. It can be excused by "limited effects capabilities", and if we have the ability to correct it, we can.

I'm not demanding absolute realism. What matters is not that the film be realistic but that it be believable, and continuity or spatial violations can stretch that for some.