logo Sign In

Post #383571

Author
ImperialFighter
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/383571/action/topic#383571
Date created
24-Oct-2009, 3:05 PM

vaderios said:

Ady I got one more error if you dont know it already.

Anyways

 I dont mind that yoda actually sits in the rock in the next shot(less is more) but at least add the blue bag in the previous shot ;)

 

-Angel

 

Yeah, this is a tricky one due to the 'brief' timing involved between the shots.  Personally, I can live with it, and won't be too bothered if Adywan has to leave things as they are....because thanks to the Prequels (ironically), I've been able to account for it like this to myself since then, lol -

 

The thing is, although Yoda is still inside the blue sack when Luke puts him down at that point during the start of that shot shown in your left-hand screenshot....the 'camera' then continues to 'pan around' to the RIGHT, away from Yoda, as it follows Luke coming towards us to retrieve his tunic (seen in 'close-up' on the right-hand side of your shot) that's hanging on the tree root.  

This needs to be seen in 'motion' of course....but due to this 'pan away' from Yoda, he ends up offscreen for approx. 2 seconds....which, given his amazing Prequel-demonstrated 'agility', means it isn't too much of a leap for me to 'imagine' that the little frog has just very speedily hopped out of the sack and onto the top log, taking his sack with him....during this 2 'offscreen' seconds before we cut to the next shot! 

I know he's elderly and all that, but since he can still levitate heavy X-wings, I reckon the little guy can therefore still manage the odd briefest spurt of 'force-speed' too....considering he's been carried around by Luke all day at this point....  :)

 

Perhaps if Adywan likes this idea enough, he can even add a 'subtle movement' to a portion of the open sack at the very start of the shot? 

This would help to really 'sell' the impression that Yoda's only just finished placing the sack down beside him (within the last 2 seconds offscreen), to indicate the merest moment that it is just finishing to 'settle down'....since he took up his new position moments ago during the very end of the preceding shot.

Well, I'm tryin' here.  ;)