Unfortunately, I have only had time to watch half of it so far, but I can't wait to finish it.

I haven't watched AOTC since it first came out on DVD, I have seen it a grand total of two times, I think. I didn't enjoy it either time, it is definitely NOT one of my favorite movies and usually I associate the thought of watching it with torture.

The appeal of TM's edit when I first read this thread all those years ago, and none of us took it seriously, was that he seemed to feel the same way about this movie I did and wanted to do such a radical edit that it would really change and improve the film in a way that conventional means of fanediting could never dream of.

As I said, I am enjoying a film I absolutely hate, kind of hard to wrap my brain around. It has been so long since I have seen any of the prequels, and the last time I heard Anakin talk was probably in some of TM's clips he posted, so strangely, the voice didn't seem at all out of place to me, but seemed pretty natural. Only issue with it to me is of course the technical aspect of it, doesn't always sound like he is in the same place as the character he is speaking with. As for Jar Jar's voice, I absolutely love it.

The actual edit itself is very well done, overall the new voice acting is a very small part of the thing as a whole, and the fanedit itself is so far beyond what I have seen anybody else do with this film, or would have thought possible. A new bench mark has definitely been set for AOTC edits. Perhaps this will inspire others to take TM's ideas and take them further.

I'd still like to see this completed someday, but honestly, I am really happy to get to see this, and do not find its rough state to hinder my enjoyment. I wish I had the money to hire TM full time, I'd love to see what he could do to that dog of a film known as Revenge of the Sith.