logo Sign In

Post #383028

Author
shanerjedi
Parent topic
Info & Ideas: ESB and ROTJ Wishlist
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/383028/action/topic#383028
Date created
21-Oct-2009, 8:06 PM

Ghost said:

Still, he doesn't look like a Jedi.  It is a consistency issue.  And yes, Luke was that good because he defeated Vader later in the movie.  You guys would say that Luke in ROTJ is about the same as Anakin in AOTC.  Right?  Yoda is the best in the business, Luke should be close by then.  He was trained a little from Obi-Wan to.

 

It shouldn't be about how good Luke was guys, the battle is lame compared to every other battle in these movies.  We should see more in space rather than a dragged out SB battle.  It should be harder for Lando to even get in the DS.  Ani and Obi in ROTS didn't just fly into Greivous's ship.  There is more to show in space and less to see on the SB.

 

Listen, these movies bring up plot and story points that need resolution. That's a key to storytelling. And this is Jabba. A baddie we've heard about in the preceding two films. So he's been set up and then you want to ditch him for what? More fx and battles in space? Sorry but the pacing of this whole battle scene is just fine.