Darth Venal said:

RoccondilRinon:

Their flaws are superficial and smaller-scale: editing, dialogue, acting and the occasional effects failure or strained suspension of disbelief.

Fucking hell, you think those things are superficial? What exactly would you consider an important factor of film?

That's really a PT thread question which deserves a PT thread answer.

I think PT is as much a problem as ROTJ but it offers opportunities that ROTJ doesn't (more aliens and masked characters which can have dialogue altered and less attachment to original performances so more room to be radical without jumping up and down on treasured memories).

So there is more room to do work on the PT (if someone wants to put the hard graft in).

ROTJ is a tighter space to work in but there is more that already works to pull out a polish so there are possibilities either way.