shanerjedi said:

Enigmas said:

I do agree TGI it is a bit odd of Luke, I don't know how I feel about taking it out. Just for clarification; are you suggesting Ady remove or replace it ?

The debate is this: Does Luke figure it out in ESB or when Yoda tells him in RotJ?

I don't think there is a question, Luke knows in his gut in ESB, hence the line: "Search your feelings you know it to be true!" followed by "NOOOOOOOOOO!!!". The discussion with Yoda in RotJ was there to remind casual fans of what had happened.

IMO anyway.