Nightmare before Christmas (is this a Halloween movie or a Christmas movie? I either watch it for both or call it somewhere inbetween and watch it at Thanksgiving)
Charlie Brown and the Great Pumpkin
Sleepy Hollow
Disney's Ichabod Crane
Thriller
Young Frankenstein
My Boyfriend's Back

And I picked up a copy of Monster Squad a year or two ago. I'm a little nervous about watching it and realizing that not only is it not great... but that it's actually terrible.

I am also not a big fan of the Horror genre, but I enjoy Evil Dead. I never really thought about them as Halloween movies, though.