> "Star Wars is not the tale of Anakin's fall and redemption"
Hehe, now I know you're joking. Whether the writing was successful is one thing, but there is no disputing the story arc. It's crystal clear.
> "The series is called Star Wars not the 'Anakin Skywalker'."
Now that's just being silly.
> "We won't see that naturally but an ending to ROTJ which hints that the story continues could be interesting"
No, and Jedi doesn't end that way because the story was complete.