logo Sign In

Post #379656

Author
DePinga
Parent topic
Five live action shows
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/379656/action/topic#379656
Date created
29-Sep-2009, 12:44 PM

Well, there is a point when we benne gesserit cannot reach.

Special Editions lame scenes (Jabba on ANH, jedi rock !!!! on ROTJ...), PT extreme lameness, Young Indy, even Clone Wars animated series... ok. They are genuine shit.

But how can you put Indy IV in the same league?? It's not Raiders, but it's a good film anyway. It seems to me that after having seen so much crap from Lucas, some people need to feel that everything he touches is 100% pure shit.

The question is: Indy IV had different producers, a decent writer and good direction. That's precisely what is needed in any Star Wars future stuff. No Rick McCallum. No Lucas screenplays. Lucas stories are not bad. Every story on PT, with a decent screenwriter developing them would make an A-class film and could even inspire good acting. But in the end, screenplays evolved to shit, and no director can make a decent film with shit scripts.

Anyway, the only thing I needed to know if i would buy with the live action shows is that Rick McCallum is on the boat. If that is true, that boat will sink for sure.