To a degree I would agree, GI. I posted my niggles back on the first page (I think) as far as what would be the perfect SE version for me. But whether ANH:R is more timeless than the original, I think it is a matter of simply being able to make me feel like 7 years old again and remembering what it was like seeing STAR WARS for the first time - as in, WOW, I didn't know that was possible!

I may have mentioned it before, but regardless of the emperor's theme in the briefing room, or the Duel of the Fates while Ben and Vader are having at it, the Falcon escape and the Last Battle always get me jumping up and down.