Leper Messiah TR said:
yeah, and they didn´t use cgi last time I looked

whatever, either you get what authenticity to the source is or you don´t - pointless to argue any more

The comics didn't use CGI because comics CAN'T use CGI. They also can't use audio, or moving pictures. So you're saying that the film shouldn't have used audio and moving pictures? It was strongly implied that Rorschach's mask was constantly changing with his emotions. No, it wasn't even implied, it was stated outright.

Authenticity can't be slavish. The Lord of the Rings films would've been bogged down if they'd included Tom Bombadil. The new Star Trek would have been hamfisted and boring if it would've been completely "authentic."

Also, I'm still waiting for how you could possibly have thought that Doc Manhattan was in on Veidt's plan.