As I said over on the other thread no one has a problem with an expression of personal taste or opinion.

What upset a lot of people like myself was his basically saying that black was white and up was down.

While Ady has shown great magnanimity here in responding to those posts, Mr Ghostface started out saying that ANH:R was nothing special and that the praise heaped on it was down to our ignorance and then shifted it to say that video editing isn't that complicated.

These projects aren't just edits.

They are deconstructions and reconstructions of the original films with brand new elements of sound and vision and that is really, really hardwork.

Even someone who hates every single addition and subtraction has to recognise that it not easy to do what he has done.

What was said back then was the antithesis of saying it how it is.

But chin up Darth Venal you are here now and you will find us (on the whole) a very friendly and helpful bunch of souls so continue as you have started and when you are ready make our jaws drop when we see your work.